Rooba
/
boinc
mirror of https://github.com/BOINC/boinc.git
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity
Page: Docker design alternatives
Pages
API Implementation ATI Radeon Account managers AccountControl AccountManagement AccountManagers Adaptive Replication AdminAlphaTest AdminApprovedProjects AdminDepLibs AdminDepLibsCurl AdminDepLibsOpenSSL AdminDepLibsSqlite AdminDepLibsZlib AdminInstallerMac AdminInstallerUnix AdminInstallerWin AdminLocalize AdminReleaseAndroid AdminReleaseManagement AdminRoles AdminTasks AdminWrappers Advanced view AlphaInstructions AndroidBoinc AndroidBoincImpl AndroidBoincTesting AndroidBoincTodo AndroidBuildApp AndroidBuildClient AndroidBuildStatus AndroidGuiDiscuss Anonymous platform AppCoprocessor AppDebug AppDebugAndroid AppDebugWin AppDev AppFiltering AppIntro AppLibraries AppMultiThread AppPlan AppPlanSpec AppVersion AppVersionNew Apple Metal Support AssignedWork Assimilation introduction Assimilators in C Assimilators in scripting languages AutoFlops AutoUpdate BOINC Client BOINC Data directory BOINC Help BOINC Manager BOINC Security BOINC screensaver BOINC apps (introduction) BOINC community BOINC events BOINC overview BOINC projects BOINC software development BOINConPhones BackendLogic BackendPrograms BackendState BackendUtilities BadgeDoc BadgesOld BashCommandCompletion BasicApi BasicConcepts BerkeleyTasks BetaTest BlackList BoincBasics BoincContributersCall BoincDocker BoincFiles BoincGovernanceWorkingGroups BoincIntro BoincLite BoincPapers BoincPlatforms BoincPmcPage BoincPr BoincProjectsCall BoincSecurity Boinccmd tool BuildClientProcedure BuildMacApp Building BOINC on Unix Building BOINC software CamelCase CancelJobs CertSig Changes to this Wiki Choosing and joining projects Client configuration Client release notes ClientAppConfig ClientDataModel ClientFiles ClientFsm ClientLogic ClientOpaque ClientSched ClientSchedOctTen ClientSchedOld ClientSchedVersionFour ClientSetupLogicWin ClientSetupLogicWinFileLayout ClientSetupLogicWinSix ClientSetupLogicWinSixCleanup ClientSetupWinSix ClientSim CloudServer CodeSigning CodingStyle CommIntro Command line job submission CompileApp CompileAppLinux CompileAppWin CompileClient CompileWithWxWidgets CompoundApps Computation credit Computing with BOINC CondorBoinc ConferenceList Contact BOINC ContributePage Controlling BOINC remotely CoreClient CpuSched Create a BOINC server (cookbook) CreateProjectCookbook Creating a skin for the BOINC Manager Creating custom installers CreditAlt CreditGeneralized CreditNew CreditNotes CreditOptions CreditProposal CreditStats CrossProjectUserId CudaApps DataBase DataFlow DbDump DbIds DbPurge DebugClientWin DeleteFile Deploy Linux apps using VirtualBox (cookbook) DesignKeywords DesktopGrid DevMethodologies DevProcess DevProjects DevProjects_New DevQualityAssurance Development_Workflow DiagnosticsApi DirHierarchy DiskManagement Docker and WSL Docker app cookbook Docker app implementation Docker apps Docker design alternatives Docker universal app web interface Docker universal app DownloadInfo DownloadOther DrupalConversion DrupalIntegration EastCoast08 Editing computing preferences with the BOINC Manager EmBoinc EmailChangeNotification EmailLists Error handling (cookbook) Error handling (introduction) ErrorReference Error_Abortingtask_Exceededdisklimit Error_Cantdeletepreviousstatefile Error_Givinguponupload Error_Schedulerrequestfailed ExampleApps FileCompression FileDeleter FileList FileUpload FortranApps Fossils GPU computing GPUApp GSoC_13 GdprCompliance GetFile GetFileList GitMigration Global prefs override.xml Going public GpuSched GpuSync GpuWorkFetch GraphicsApi GraphicsApiOld GraphicsApps GraphicsHtml GridIntegration GuiRpc GuiRpcProtocol GuiUrls HTMLGfx HarzPics Heat and energy considerations Home Homogeneous App Version Homogeneous Redundancy Host identification and merging HostId HostMeasurement How BOINC works HtmlOps Initialization files InstallDrupal Installing BOINC on Debian or Ubuntu Installing BOINC on EC2 Installing BOINC on Fedora Installing BOINC on Gentoo Installing BOINC on Ubuntu Installing BOINC Installing on Android Installing on FreeBSD Installing on Linux Installing on MacOS Installing on Windows IntermediateUpload JavaApps Job processing (cookbook) Job processing (introduction) Job replication JobEst JobIn JobIntro JobKeywords JobPinning JobPrioritization JobReplication JobSched JobSizeMatching JobStage JobStatus JobSubmission JobTemplates KeySetup LammpsRemote LdapSupport Linux file permissions Linux DEB and RPM support Linux installer LocalityNew LocalityScheduling Locating stolen computers LogExtension LogRotate LowLatency MacBacktrace MacBuild MacDeveloper MacDeveloperProjects Maintain your BOINC project MakeProject ManagerImpl ManagerMenus MasterUrl MediaWiki MemoryManagement Missing Linux shared libraries MpiApps MultiHost MultiSize MultiUser MultiUserPriority MysqlConfig Network related problems NetworkApps NonCpuIntensive Notifications OpenCL Applications OpenCL CPU applications OpenId OpenclCpu OptionsApi OrgGrid OtherProjectDocs PMC_Minutes PMC_Minutes_2017_12_15 PMC_Minutes_2018_01_10 PageTemplates PasswordHash PayPalDonations Per user file sandbox PerAppCredit PersFileXfer PhpDb PhysicalFileManagement PlanClassFunc PortalFeatures PowerManagement Preferences PreferencesXml Prefs2 PrefsImpl PrefsOverride PrefsPresets PrefsReference PrefsReference_Time PrefsRemodel PrefsUnification PrepareLinuxBuildMachine Process_proposals ProfileScreen ProjectConfigFile ProjectDaemons ProjectDefaults ProjectGovernance ProjectLaunch ProjectMain ProjectNews ProjectNotices ProjectOptions ProjectPapers ProjectPlan ProjectSecurity ProjectSelect ProjectSkin ProjectSpecificPrefs ProjectSponsors ProjectTasks ProofOfOwnership Proposal_ProjectSimpleAccountCreation ProtectionFromSpam Proxy servers ProxyServer PyMw PythonAppDev PythonApps PythonFramework PythonMw PythonMysql QuickStart RecentChanges Reduce_usage_of_authenticator Reduce_usage_of_authenticator_implementation ReleaseNotes RemoteInputFiles RemoteJob RemoteJobs RemoteLogs RemoteOutputFiles RemoteOverview Reporting client bugs ResearchProjects RightToErasure RpcAuth RpcPolicy RpcProtocol RpmSpec Running Linux apps on BOINC RuntimeEstimation SandBox SandboxUser SchedMatch Scientist interface ScreensaverEnhancements ScreensaverLogic SecureHttp SecurityIssues SendFile Server release notes Server trouble‐shooting ServerComponents ServerDirs ServerIntro ServerSecurity ServerStatus ServerTestInstructions ServerUpdates Simple view Simple attach usage SimpleAttach SingleJob SingleJobImpl SkinExamples SoftwareAddon SoftwareDevelopment SoftwarePrereqsUnix SoftwareTesting SolarisClient SolrIntegration Source code map SourceCode SourceCodeGit SourceCodeGit_Commands SourceCodeGit_Windows SourceCodeGit_WindowsKeygen SourceCodeGit_WorkFlow SourceCodeSvn Sporadic Applications Standard assimilators Standard validators StartTool Starting BOINC on boot (Unix) StatsXml StatusApi StolenComputers Stop or start BOINC daemon after boot StripChart StyleSheets SuperHost TeamDiscussion TeamImport Teams TemplateImages TermsOfUse The BOINC out of box experience The BOINC test drive ToolUpgrade Tools for MacOS TranslateIntro TranslateProject Translate_Coordination TranslationSystem TreeThreader TrickleApi TrickleImpl TrickleMessages TroubleshootClient TroubleshootClient_New Troubleshooting Tutorial_BOINCApplicationDevelopmentLifecycle Tutorial_DeployingVMApplications UnixClientPackage UnixProjectPackage UpdateVersions UploadStatistics Usage rules User manual UserJobs UserOptInConsent Using BOINC with modem, ISDN and VPN connections UsingSvn ValidationLowLevel Validators in C Validators in scripting languages Validators VboxApps Vboxwrapper release notes VersionDiff VersionHistory VersionPathSorter VirtualBox Plan VirtualBox VirtualCampusSupercomputerCenter VirtualMachines Virtualbox Shared Directories VmApps VmCompatibility VmServer Volunteer VolunteerComputing VolunteerDataArchival VolunteerRecruit VolunteerStorage WSL apps WatchDog Weak account key WebCache WebConfig WebForum WebResources WebRpc WebSubmit WebTemplateProposal WhyUseBoinc WikiTodo WinMulticore WindowsIssues WordPressInt WorkDistribution WorkFetchMaxConcurrent WorkGeneration WorkShop07 WorkShop07_BoincGrid WorkShop07_BoincSched WorkShop07_InterpretedApps WorkShop07_PubBoincOne WorkShop07_PubBoincTwo WorkShop07_SecurityGroup WorkShop07_SimplifyApp WorkShop07_Summary WorkShop07_VirtualMachines WorkShop07_WebCode WorkShop08 WorkShop08_WorkshopProceedings WorkShop09 WorkShop09_BatchSched WorkShop09_InterprocComm WorkShop09_ScientistUsability WorkShop09_UserIssues WorkShop09_VmApps WorkShop10 WorkShop10_VmApps WorkShop10_VolunteerIssues WorkShop11 WorkShop11_HackFest WorkShop11_HackFest_Android WorkShop11_MultiUser WorkShop12 WorkShop12_WorkshopSummary WorkShop13 WorkShop13_HackfestNotes WorkShop14 WorkShop18 WorkShop19 Worker release notes WorldWideLexicon Wrapper release notes WrapperApp XaddTool XmlFormat XmlNotes XmlStats test_RunningBoinc
5 Docker design alternatives
David Anderson edited this page 2024-11-05 13:17:00 -08:00
Table of Contents

Alternative ways to run Docker apps in BOINC on Windows:

Docker Desktop approach

Volunteers install Docker Desktop, separately from BOINC. This includes a WSL image, docker_desktop.

The Docker wrapper runs docker.exe (on Win) to create, run, and control Docker containers. Images are stored in the system-wide Docker store and are given special names to avoid conflicting with non-BOINC Docker usage.

Docker in WSL approach

Volunteers install a 'BOINC Docker WSL image' from the Windows store. This includes Podman.

The Docker wrapper runs a shell in this image, with a pipe for sending it commands (like the WSL wrapper does). It creates and runs Docker containers by sending Docker commands to this shell.

Docker images are stored within this image. There's no conflict with non-BOINC Docker usage.

Comparison

Advantages of the WSL approach:

  • Volunteer doesn't have to install Docker Desktop. Downloading and running this installer takes a lot of clicks. It's intended for developers, not consumers. I'm not sure how many volunteers will do it; probably less than 50%, maybe much lower.

  • We control what's in the BOINC Docker WSL image. In particular we can include the CRUI library (needed for checkpointing) and configure Docker to use it.

  • In the Docker Desktop approach the volunteer needs to have the UI open in order for the Docker engine to be running (is there a way to do this automatically?)

  • We don't really want the volunteer to know about Docker, or see the Docker GUI (which lets them fiddle around with images and containers, possibly breaking things).

Disadvantages of the WSL approach:

  • The BOINC Docker WSL image might be large - not sure.

Questions:

  • Is there any performance difference between the 2 approaches?
  • Can apps use GPUs in the WSL approach?
  • Can we run multithread apps in the WSL approach?

Other platforms

Linux: require volunteer to install Docker manually (and optionally CRUI)? Use this directly or run Docker inside of a Docker container? Can you do that?

Mac OS: I think we have to use Docker Desktop.

Home